, , ,

Rebuilding Trust without Abandoning Boundaries

•

Small groups talk and work around tables on a terrace overlooking a city.

Building a Shared Future without Erasing Difference

This article is part of the Human Connection Project, an interdisciplinary exploration of how people perceive, relate, belong, protect, and sometimes separate.

Section: Human Connection in Real Life
Series: From Analysis to Rebalancing
Reflection 5 of 5: Rebuilding Trust without Abandoning Boundaries

This is Article 5, and the concluding article, in the Human Connection Project series From Analysis to Rebalancing, inspired by the Human Connection Project’s analysis of the 2026 Saxony-Anhalt election.
The series has explored how separation forms, why apparent victory does not end conflict, and why a functioning system may still remain relationally disconnected. We now arrive at the practical question: what might help people rebuild relationship without surrendering necessary differences, values or boundaries?

In the previous article, we distinguished between functional integration and relational integration.

People may share institutions without sharing trust.
They may live under the same laws without feeling equally represented by them.
They may inhabit the same country while carrying very different memories of how that country came to be.
They may even agree that they need one another while continuing to experience each other primarily through suspicion.

If this is true, then institutional repair alone cannot complete the work.

Eventually another task begins: the rebuilding of relationship.

That sounds simple.
It is not.
Because relationship repair does not mean removing every disagreement.
It does not mean asking people to abandon their convictions.
It does not mean pretending all grievances are equally justified.
And it certainly does not mean tolerating dehumanization, violence or the destruction of the very conditions that make peaceful coexistence possible.

The deeper challenge is more difficult:
Can we become capable of remaining in relationship across meaningful difference without either dissolving our boundaries or turning those boundaries into permanent separation?

This may be one of the central skills required by plural societies.


1. Understanding is not agreement

Perhaps the first obstacle to repair is a misunderstanding about understanding itself.

We often behave as though attempting to understand another person’s position means moving toward agreement with it:
If I try to understand your anger, perhaps I am validating it.
If I investigate the historical causes of your resentment, perhaps I am excusing what you subsequently do with that resentment.
If I acknowledge your grievance, perhaps I weaken my own position.

But these are different processes:
Understanding is an attempt to reconstruct another person’s pathway.
Agreement is a judgment about where that pathway has led.

We can understand why someone became afraid without concluding that the object of the fear is actually dangerous.
We can understand why someone feels humiliated without agreeing with the political conclusions they draw from that humiliation.
We can understand why a community became distrustful without accepting every claim circulating within that community.

This distinction is essential because without it, curiosity itself begins to feel dangerous.
We may stop asking: How did they arrive here?
and begin only asking: How can we defeat what they believe?

Once that happens, the other person becomes primarily an argument to overcome. The relationship disappears behind the position.


2. Listen to Understand Rather Than Defeat

This brings us to one of the simplest—and perhaps most difficult—practices of relational repair:
listen to understand rather than defeat.

Ordinary political and social conversation often resembles competitive debate.
One person speaks while the other prepares a counterargument.
A weakness is detected.
A contradiction is exposed.
Evidence is deployed.
The objective becomes victory.

There are situations where rigorous debate is entirely appropriate:
Public policy requires disagreement, evidence and criticism.

But debate and relationship repair are not identical activities.

A 2024 study bringing together people who had supported opposing sides of the Brexit referendum tested a structured dialogue intervention. Rather than encouraging participants to debate who was correct, the intervention emphasized active listening, acknowledgement of the other person’s perspective and respectful discussion of real disagreement. The researchers found short-term reductions in affective polarization between participants.

One reason may be surprisingly basic: people become more receptive when they believe they have actually been heard.

The objective of listening is therefore not to silently wait for one’s turn.
It is to discover:
What does this situation look like from where you stand?
What are you afraid of losing?
What experience made this issue important to you?
What do you think people like me misunderstand about people like you?

We may still disagree afterwards.
But disagreement after understanding is different from disagreement built upon an imagined version of the other person.


3. Being understood can sometimes matter before being persuaded

Human beings do not enter disagreement as detached reasoning machines.
We bring identities.
Memories.
Status.
Belonging.
Fear.
Previous experiences of humiliation or exclusion…

And when people feel that these are being dismissed, the disagreement may become less about the original issue and increasingly about self-protection.

Research on intergroup dialogue suggests that perspective-giving—having an opportunity to explain one’s own experience and feel understood by the other side—can itself influence receptiveness. Respectful conversational acknowledgement has also been associated with greater trust and willingness to continue interacting.

This does not mean: Everyone must be made comfortable.
Nor does it mean: Every belief deserves affirmation.
It means something subtler:
before asking people to reconsider a position, it may help if they no longer feel that reconsidering it requires admitting that their entire experience was meaningless.

That is a very different psychological starting point.


4. Communicate Honestly without Humiliation

Understanding should not require dishonesty.

Sometimes disagreement is profound.
Sometimes a statement really is inaccurate.
Sometimes behaviour is discriminatory.
Sometimes a political demand violates the rights or dignity of others.

Relational repair does not require pretending otherwise.
But there is a difference between challenging a claim and humiliating the person who holds it.

Humiliation attacks status and belonging.
It says not merely: “I believe this claim is wrong.”
but something closer to: “The fact that you believe this shows what kind of inferior person you are.”

That distinction matters because identity threat can make people more defensive rather than more reflective.

This is one reason productive dialogue requires both honesty and dignity.
We should be able to say: “I understand why you are worried about this, but I do not think the evidence supports the conclusion you have reached.”
Or: “I recognize that you experienced real loss, but I cannot agree that another group should lose its rights because of it.”

The boundary remains. But the person has not been reduced to the boundary.


5. Keep the Door Open without Moving the Wall

This suggests an important principle for the entire Human Connection Project:
A healthy boundary does not necessarily require a closed door.

Some boundaries should be firm:
Human dignity.
Freedom from violence.
Equality before the law.
Protection from discrimination.
Basic democratic procedures.
The rights of minorities.

These cannot simply be negotiated away whenever social conflict becomes intense.
But defending boundaries and abandoning relationship are not the same action.

We can say: “This behaviour is unacceptable.” without saying: “Therefore you are permanently beyond relationship.”
We can reject a political claim without assuming that everyone attracted to it has an identical motive.
We can oppose discrimination while remaining interested in the insecurity that may have helped make discriminatory explanations attractive.

The distinction is important because otherwise social boundaries can create a paradox:
They successfully protect values in the immediate moment but contribute over time to the construction of increasingly isolated identity communities that no longer encounter one another except through hostility.

The goal should therefore not be boundarylessness.
It should be bounded connection.


6. Acknowledge Legitimate Grievances—Even When the Story Surrounding Them Is Imperfect

One of the hardest situations arises when a real grievance becomes attached to a questionable explanation.

Someone may genuinely have lost economic security. But blame migrants.
Someone may genuinely feel ignored by institutions. But conclude that an elaborate conspiracy explains it.
Someone may genuinely experience cultural dislocation. But respond by treating another population as inherently threatening.

If we attack only the explanation while ignoring the underlying experience, we may inadvertently strengthen the explanation.
The person hears: “Your interpretation is wrong.” as: “Your experience never mattered.”

But if we accept the interpretation merely because the pain behind it is genuine, we create another problem:
We confuse empathy with accuracy.

A better response separates the layers.
The loss can be real even when the explanation is incomplete.
The fear can be real even when the perceived threat is exaggerated.
The grievance can deserve attention even when the proposed solution would harm others.

This separation allows societies to address pain without allowing pain to become an unlimited moral license.


7. Trust Cannot Simply Be Requested

After conflict, institutions and leaders often ask people to restore trust.
But trust does not operate like a decision.
We cannot simply announce: “From tomorrow, trust one another again.”
Trust grows through prediction:
“I begin trusting you because I repeatedly discover that your behaviour broadly matches what you say.”
“You listen when you promised to listen.”

The procedure that was supposed to be fair is actually fair:
“The institution that claimed to represent me demonstrates that my participation has consequences.”
“The person who apologized behaves differently next time.”

In this sense, trust is accumulated evidence.

This is why relational integration requires repeated experience rather than one symbolic reconciliation event.

Research on intergroup contact has repeatedly found that meaningful interaction between members of different groups can reduce prejudice, particularly when people interact under conditions involving relatively equal status, shared goals, cooperation and institutional support.

More recent psychological work has examined how ordinary encounters across group boundaries may interrupt habitual patterns of stereotyping and threat perception, potentially allowing new patterns of response to develop over time.

Trust therefore grows less through declarations of unity than through many smaller experiences of reliable relationship.


8. Do Things Together—Not Only Talk about One Another

This leads to another important lesson.

Dialogue matters.
But dialogue alone is not enough.
Groups that distrust one another need opportunities not only to discuss their differences but also to experience cooperation.

Repair becomes more believable when people discover:
We can actually accomplish something together.

A neighbourhood project.
A school initiative.
A community garden.
A local cultural activity.
A shared workplace problem.
A volunteer organization.
An environmental restoration project.
A common challenge affecting everyone.

Classic intergroup-contact research emphasized four particularly useful conditions:
equal status,
common goals,
cooperation and institutional support.
Later research has shown that positive contact can still have benefits when these ideal conditions are not all perfectly present, but meaningful interaction and cooperation remain especially valuable. (APA overview: “Dismantling Hate”)

This is significant because relationships do not grow only through exchanging beliefs.
They also grow through shared activity.

Sometimes people discover one another differently while repairing a playground than while debating national identity.
Something changes when the person previously known primarily as one of them becomes: the person who helped me solve this.


9. Create Shared Goals without Demanding Shared Identities

Common projects can help, but another danger appears here.

Societies sometimes attempt integration by constructing a single identity and asking everyone to fit inside it:
One correct history.
One legitimate culture.
One interpretation of belonging.
One acceptable way of being a member of the society.

This may produce apparent unity while pushing differences underground.

A more resilient form of connection does not require everyone to become the same.
People can retain regional identities.
Religious identities.
Cultural memories.
Political disagreements.
Different experiences of history.
Different relationships to place.

The challenge is to create a sufficiently strong shared layer above or between them.

Not: “We are connected because our differences have disappeared.”
But: “We are connected because despite our differences, there are things we recognize as jointly ours:”
A town.
A constitution.
A school.
A landscape.
A language.
A public institution.
A neighbourhood.
A responsibility.
A future…

Research into intergroup relations has long suggested that shared or superordinate goals can reduce antagonism by creating situations in which different groups have reasons to cooperate rather than compete.
The Brexit dialogue intervention discussed earlier similarly ended with participants working together around a shared concern without asking them to relinquish their original political identities. (Read the 2024 study)

The shared identity does not have to eliminate the smaller identities. It can coexist with them.


10. Shared Institutions Must Become Experienced as Shared

Article 4 distinguished between functional integration and relational integration.
Here that distinction becomes practical.

A school can be administratively shared but socially segregated.
A parliament can constitutionally represent everyone while some groups experience themselves as permanently unheard.
A public institution can operate efficiently while appearing culturally distant from the people it serves.
A country can possess common institutions without those institutions being experienced as genuinely common.

Therefore the challenge is not merely to create shared institutions.
It is to create experiences of shared ownership within them.

That involves questions such as:
Who participates?
Who is visible?
Who is listened to?
Who holds authority?
Whose history appears in the institution’s story?
Who believes advancement is realistically open to them?
Who feels that complaining will produce investigation rather than dismissal?

UNESCO’s work on dialogue for social cohesion similarly emphasizes that dialogue works best when it is connected to participation, trust-building, inclusive institutions and opportunities for communities to contribute to a shared vision of the common good. (UNESCO: “Dialogue for Social Cohesion”)

Relational integration therefore cannot be produced solely through communication campaigns. People need to encounter institutional evidence that they actually belong.


11. Shared Narratives Should Have Room for More Than One Memory

Communities also live inside stories.

Who suffered?
Who sacrificed?
Who built the society?
Who caused the conflict?
Who liberated whom?
Who was ignored?
Who deserves gratitude?
Whose version became history?

When only one side’s memory receives public legitimacy, relational integration becomes difficult.

But the solution is not necessarily to replace one official story with another.
A mature shared narrative may need to contain apparently uncomfortable combinations.

German reunification, for example, can be remembered as liberation from authoritarian rule and as a period of profound biographical disruption for many eastern Germans.
Migration can create opportunity and cultural enrichment and generate real adaptation pressures in particular communities.
Economic modernization can improve prosperity and destroy occupations and social worlds.

Historical complexity is not weakness.
It may actually create more room for relationship.
Because a shared narrative becomes more believable when people can recognize at least part of their own experience inside it.


12. Do Not Force Premature Reconciliation

There is another temptation in repairing conflict: to move too quickly.

We have discussed it.
We apologized.
The policy changed.
The war is over.
The election is finished.
The institution has been reformed.
Now let us move on.

But people do not heal according to administrative schedules.
Some consequences of conflict remain material.
Some remain psychological.
Some are passed between generations.
Some wounds require acknowledgement before cooperation becomes possible, others may never disappear completely.

Pressuring people to reconcile before they feel heard can create performative harmony:
the appearance of unity without the underlying relationship.

This does not mean societies should remain indefinitely trapped in grievance.
It means that moving forward and remembering are not necessarily opposites.
Sometimes the way forward passes through an honest encounter with what happened.


13. Leave Room for Uncertainty

Polarization thrives on certainty:
We understand exactly why they behave this way.
Their motives are obvious.
People like that never change.
Our side would never do the same.
…

But human behaviour is rarely so clean.
One useful counterweight is what psychologists sometimes describe as epistemic humility:
recognizing the limits of one’s own knowledge and considering context and alternative perspectives.

Research across several political and social conflicts has found that forms of wise reasoning—including intellectual humility, attention to context and attempts to integrate different perspectives—are associated with more positive attitudes toward opposing groups and lower levels of attitude polarization. (Read the study in Nature Communications)

Humility does not mean believing nothing.
It means leaving enough cognitive space for sentences such as:
“I may be missing something.”
“My group may also contribute to this dynamic.”
“Their motives may be more varied than I assume.”
“Some of my evidence may be incomplete.”
“I can revise my understanding without betraying my values.”

That small opening can be relationally powerful.


14. Repair Does Not Require Forgetting Power

There is an important caution here:
Calls for empathy and dialogue can themselves become unfair if they ignore differences in power.

The person being discriminated against should not carry the same responsibility for reconciliation as the institution discriminating against them.
Victims of violence should not be pressured into dialogue for the comfort of those who harmed them.
A marginalized group should not be told that social cohesion requires quietly tolerating continuing inequality.

Relationship repair therefore needs both connection and justice:
Dialogue cannot substitute for fair laws.
Empathy cannot substitute for accountability.
Personal goodwill cannot substitute for institutional reform.
At the same time, laws and reforms cannot by themselves generate trust.

We return again to the same principle:
functional and relational repair need one another.

Justice without relationship can produce compliance without belonging.
Relationship without justice can produce superficial harmony over continuing harm.
Rebalancing requires both.


15. Expect Trust to Grow Unevenly

We should also abandon the expectation that repair proceeds smoothly.

Human relationships rarely improve in a straight line.
A positive encounter may increase trust.
A new conflict may reduce it.
An institution may make progress.
Then a scandal reactivates old suspicions.
One generation may develop closer relationships while another continues carrying memories of earlier injury.

This is not necessarily proof that repair has failed.
Relational integration may be better imagined as continuous rebalancing:
People move closer.
Something destabilizes the relationship.
They adjust.
New people enter.
Circumstances change.
Old narratives are reconsidered.
New inequalities emerge.
The system adapts again.

This is why the final destination cannot simply be “reconciliation achieved.”

There may be no permanent final equilibrium.
There is instead the continuing capacity to detect imbalance before it hardens into separation.


16. Make the Future Credible

There is one final principle that connects almost everything in this series:
People need something to move toward.

A society cannot build cohesion entirely by telling people what they must stop doing:
Stop hating.
Stop distrusting.
Stop polarizing.
Stop remembering the conflict in that way.
Stop supporting divisive movements.
Stop seeing yourselves as outsiders.
…

These instructions describe restraints.
They do not describe a future.

For connection to become attractive, people need a credible answer to another question:
What are we building together?

Not an abstract promise that everything will improve.
A believable future in which different people can imagine a place for themselves.
A future where participation matters.
Where contribution is recognized.
Where children have opportunities.
Where institutions can be trusted enough to correct their own failures.
Where disagreement does not automatically imply exclusion.
Where belonging is not reserved for those who resemble the current majority.

UNESCO’s work on intercultural dialogue and social cohesion emphasizes this future-oriented dimension: dialogue is not merely a way to reduce tension, but also a means of developing trust and shared responses to common challenges.

A shared future is therefore not merely a political slogan. It is a relational resource.


17. From Winning to Sharing

This brings us back to where this series turned.

Article 3 asked what happens after someone wins.
Article 4 asked what happens when a new system works, but people within it do not yet experience it as fully shared.
Article 5 brings those questions together.

Perhaps the deepest challenge after conflict is not determining who prevailed.
It is discovering whether the people who must continue living together can gradually move from: winner and loser toward: participant and participant.
From: your institution imposed on me toward: our institution, which I can also help shape.
From: your history against mine toward: a shared history spacious enough to contain both.
From: I need to defeat you in order to protect myself toward: we need boundaries that protect us without permanently imprisoning us on opposite sides of them.

This does not require agreement on everything.
It requires something perhaps more difficult:
the capacity to remain connected while disagreement remains real.


Rebalancing is not surrender

Human connection is sometimes misunderstood as:
softness,
compromise,
avoidance of disagreement,
a reluctance to draw lines…

But the kind of connection explored throughout this project asks for something much harder.

It asks us to maintain boundaries without dehumanizing the person on the other side.
To acknowledge suffering without surrendering critical thought.
To defend values without turning moral certainty into humiliation.
To listen seriously without promising agreement.
To recognize difference without immediately turning difference into threat.
To repair trust without pretending trust has already been earned.
To build common institutions without demanding identical identities.
And to imagine a shared future without erasing the different paths through which people arrived there.

Perhaps this is what rebalancing ultimately means.
Not eliminating tension.
Not achieving permanent harmony.
Not winning once and for all.

But developing the individual and collective capacity to notice:
when protection becomes exclusion,
when conviction becomes contempt,
when belonging becomes possession,
when grievance becomes identity,
and when necessary boundaries begin turning into permanent walls.

Then adjusting.
Again.
And again.

Because human connection is not a state we finally reach.
It is something we continually learn how to maintain.


Where This Leads

This article concludes the first series of From Analysis to Rebalancing, but it does not close the larger Human Connection Project.

The series began by asking why people separate.
That question led us through identity, belonging, protection, grievance, conflict, victory, institutional integration, trust and finally relational repair.

Along the way, one pattern has become increasingly visible:

Many of the mechanisms that divide human beings begin with functions that are not inherently destructive.

We need identity.
We need boundaries.
We need belonging.
We protect what matters to us.
We form alliances.
We preserve memories.
We pursue goals.
We defend communities.
We create institutions.

The problem often begins not with the existence of these functions, but when they become too rigid, too threatened, too exclusive or too disconnected from the effects they produce on others.

That observation opens the next layer of the Human Connection Project.

From here, the inquiry can move beyond political and historical cases and return to the deeper interdisciplinary questions underneath them:
How does the human brain construct “us” and “them”?
How do perception, emotion, memory and embodied experience shape whom we trust?
Why do some boundaries remain flexible while others harden?
What allows people to remain psychologically secure enough to encounter difference without immediately defending against it?

And perhaps most importantly:

Can greater awareness of how connection and separation are produced help us intervene earlier—before imbalance becomes conflict?

The series therefore ends not with a formula for harmony, but with a different way of looking.

Instead of asking only: Who is right?
we can also ask: What is happening to the relationship?

Instead of asking only: Which side won?
we can ask: What will make the next conflict less likely?

And instead of asking only: How do we protect what matters to us?
we might also ask: How can we protect it without unnecessarily destroying the connections on which our future may also depend?

That is where the inquiry continues.


Sources & Further Reading

Tausch, Birtel, Górska et al. (2024), Communications Psychology — “A post-Brexit intergroup contact intervention reduces affective polarization between Leavers and Remainers short-term.” An experimental study of structured, respectful dialogue between people holding opposing political identities. Read the study

American Psychological Association — “Dismantling Hate.” An accessible overview of intergroup contact theory, including equal status, common goals, cooperation and institutional support. Read the overview

Stefaniak et al., Nature Reviews Psychology — “Towards a habit-rupture model of intergroup contact in everyday settings.” Examines how everyday encounters may interrupt habitual forms of intergroup perception and prejudice. Read the review

Brienza, Kung & Chao (2021), Nature Communications — “Wise reasoning, intergroup positivity, and attitude polarization across contexts.” Research connecting epistemic humility and contextual reasoning with reduced polarization. Read the study

Zhou et al. — “The Extended Contact Hypothesis: A Meta-analysis on 20 Years of Research.” A meta-analysis examining whether awareness of positive relationships between members of different groups can improve intergroup attitudes. Oxford University Research Archive

UNESCO — “Dialogue for Social Cohesion.” Examines how dialogue can support trust, participation and relationship repair in divided societies. Explore the publication

UNESCO — Intercultural Dialogue Programme. Research and practice concerning polarization, social inclusion, trust, governance and dialogue across difference. Explore the programme

Leave a Reply