Participation, Shared Influence, and the Decisions That Shape Care
Samir has become a regular participant in the community repair project introduced in Article 2.
He repairs furniture, exchanges ideas with other volunteers, and helps newcomers find their way around the workshop. What began as an invitation has developed into a place where several people’s knowledge and resources come together.
One afternoon, an organiser shows him a draft publicity leaflet.
It includes his photograph and describes how the project helps immigrants integrate into the community.
Samir hesitates.
He appreciates the welcome he received. But the leaflet presents him mainly as someone who has benefited from the organisers’ generosity. It says little about the work he contributes or the relationships that have developed.
“Could we describe this as something we do together?” he asks. “And I’d like to decide whether my photograph is used.”
The organiser feels surprised.
“We thought you’d be pleased. Your story shows why the project matters.”
This is a continuation of an illustrative example, not a documented case.
The disagreement reveals something the successful repair afternoons had not resolved:
Samir has a place in the activity. But does he have a say in how that activity—and his place within it—is understood?
The previous article explored agency within ongoing assistance. This article extends the question to collective arrangements:
When people receive support or contribute to a project, what allows them to influence the decisions that shape it?
1. Taking Part and Having Influence Are Different
Participation can mean several things.
Someone attends an event. Someone helps carry out a task. Someone shares an experience. Someone advises the organisers. Someone helps decide the project’s priorities…
All involve participation, but they provide different kinds of influence.
Samir’s repair knowledge can change how a chair is restored. That does not necessarily give him influence over publicity, opening hours, spending, or the project’s purpose.
This distinction matters because a project can become highly participatory in its activities while remaining tightly controlled in its decisions.
The organisers may welcome contributions enthusiastically. They may also assume that planning belongs to the people who founded the project.
That assumption deserves examination rather than immediate condemnation.
Founders may carry responsibilities others do not see: arranging insurance, maintaining accounts, negotiating access to the room, or answering to funders. Their experience and accountability matter.
But those responsibilities do not automatically settle every question.
Knowing how to manage a budget does not give someone exclusive authority to describe another person’s life. Having established the workshop does not mean its future participants have nothing relevant to say about its development.
The practical task is to identify which decisions are being made, who is affected, and how responsibility and influence should connect.
“Everyone is welcome” answers a question about entry.
It does not yet answer a question about power.
2. Consultation Needs a Connection to What Happens Next
The distinction between being heard and possessing influence has a long history in participation research.
In “A Ladder of Citizen Participation,” Sherry Arnstein distinguished forms of participation according to the power citizens possessed over outcomes. Her account challenged processes in which people could express views while decision-makers retained control. It arose from particular American planning and social programmes, rather than offering a universal measure for every relationship.
The question remains useful for a community project:
What can participants actually change?
An organiser might ask Samir whether he likes the leaflet. But if the design has already been approved and his objection cannot affect publication, the question provides little influence.
Similarly, a survey may collect suggestions about workshop hours while leaving participants unaware that only one time slot is available.
Consultation can be valuable even when participants do not make the final decision. Its value depends partly on honesty about its scope and a meaningful response to what people contribute.
Archon Fung’s framework for participation examines three dimensions: who participates, how people communicate and make decisions, and how their discussions connect with public action. This approach helps move beyond counting meetings or attendees toward examining the arrangement itself.
Applied to the workshop, the organisers could explain:
“We can change the wording and images. The funder requires us to explain the project’s purpose, but we can discuss how to do that accurately.”
That statement makes the space for influence visible.
After discussion, participants should also be able to learn what changed, what did not, and why.
A rejected suggestion can still receive serious consideration. An accepted suggestion needs follow-through.
Without that connection, listening risks becoming a recurring activity through which the organisation learns about people while people remain unable to affect the organisation.
3. Having a Say Does Not Mean Deciding Everything
Shared influence does not require every participant to possess identical authority over every matter.
Different decisions involve different rights, knowledge, and responsibilities.
Samir’s choice about whether to appear in publicity is different from a collective decision about how the workshop spends its funds. A decision about equipment safety may require expertise that a vote cannot replace.
The following arrangement is one possible starting point for the illustrative project:
| Decision | A possible way to allocate influence |
|---|---|
| Use of someone’s photograph or personal story | Ask the person, respect their choice, and agree on the portrayal. |
| Workshop hours and everyday routines | Seek input from affected participants and decide through a clear, agreed process. |
| Spending within a designated activity budget | Give a participant group defined authority, information, and accountability. |
| Safety requirements and formal obligations | Keep responsibility with the appropriate people, explain constraints, and invite workable alternatives. |
This is a practical proposal, not a validated model.
Its purpose is to make distinctions explicit.
Some decisions belong primarily to the individual. Others require collective negotiation. Some can be delegated. Others remain attached to professional or organisational duties.
Clarity protects participants from promises that cannot be fulfilled. It also protects organisers from the expectation that sharing influence means abandoning responsibility.
Importantly, the boundaries themselves may need discussion.
A rule can reflect a genuine obligation. It can also reflect a habit that has never been reconsidered.
“We have always done it this way” provides historical information. It does not establish that the arrangement remains appropriate.
Shared influence becomes more meaningful when participants can question the process as well as contribute within it.
4. Contribution Can Change What a Project Understands Itself to Be
Samir’s objection concerns more than a photograph.
The leaflet tells a story about helpers and beneficiaries. His experience suggests a more complicated relationship: people receive support, contribute knowledge, develop friendships, and create something together.
Recognising this does not erase the original welcome. It expands the account of what followed.
Elinor Ostrom’s work on coproduction examines how people outside an organisation can contribute to producing goods and services alongside its regular providers. Her analysis draws attention to capacities that are missed when citizens are understood only as recipients. The paper examines public-service cases; applying the idea to this workshop is an interpretive extension.
The repair project makes that possibility concrete.
Organisers provide access, tools, continuity, and coordination. Participants bring knowledge, time, objects, questions, and relationships. The activity depends on their combination.
Yet producing something together does not automatically mean governing it together.
Samir can contribute substantially while remaining excluded from planning. Others can be valued for their practical labour while their criticism is dismissed.
This creates a useful distinction:
Shared activity can create shared capacity. Shared influence requires additional arrangements.
Participants might help formulate priorities, join planning discussions, manage part of a budget, or review how the project presents its work.
These arrangements can also change the project’s purpose.
A workshop initially organised to help newcomers might gradually understand itself as a neighbourhood space for repair, learning, and connection, while retaining specific support for people facing barriers.
That change should emerge through discussion. Neither founders nor newer participants possess the whole account of what the project has become.
5. Who Gets to Represent the Experience?
Publicity brings a particular form of power into view: the ability to tell the story.
An organisation may describe someone as vulnerable, rescued, transformed, or successfully integrated.
The description might contain elements of truth. It can still leave out what the person considers important.
Samir may recognise that he received welcome and language support. He may also want his craft, humour, friendships, and contribution to appear in the account.
His objection need not mean that he rejects the help.
He is questioning the position assigned to him within the story.
A more careful process would ask whether he wants to appear, let him review the relevant wording, and respect a decision to decline. The project could explain its value through descriptions of activities and collective outcomes without requiring one participant to make their personal life public.
Refusing publicity should not quietly become evidence of insufficient gratitude.
Nor should Samir have to represent all immigrants. His experience belongs to him. Another participant may understand the project differently.
The same issue appears in services and consultation groups.
One articulate person can become the preferred representative of a much wider population. Their account may be valuable, but it cannot stand in for every experience.
Projects need room for different perspectives, including those that are difficult to summarise in an encouraging success story.
Learning sometimes begins with information that disrupts the organisation’s preferred account of itself.
6. Influence Must Be Accessible—and Optional
Inviting people to a planning meeting does not guarantee that they can participate meaningfully.
The meeting may occur during working hours. Documents may use unfamiliar language. Discussion may move too quickly. Transport, childcare, fatigue, or the cost of attendance may exclude people.
Others may remain quiet because they are unsure whether disagreement will affect their welcome.
A project needs to examine these conditions rather than interpreting attendance as interest and absence as indifference.
Practical responses could include sharing information beforehand, using clear language, providing translation where needed, accepting written or spoken contributions, and offering more than one way to raise a concern.
Where participation demands substantial work, organisations should consider payment or other appropriate support. Advice, preparation, translation, and representation all take time.
At the same time, influence must remain an opportunity rather than a new condition of belonging.
Samir may enjoy repairing furniture and dislike committee meetings. Someone else may attend mainly for company or bring an object they cannot repair.
They should not have to become organisers to remain welcome.
This preserves a central commitment of the series: dignity and access to care do not depend on productivity, confidence, gratitude, or leadership.
Participation should also avoid creating a new inner circle.
If only confident, fluent, or frequently available participants acquire influence, the project may reproduce exclusion in a different form. Rotating roles, seeking missing perspectives, and maintaining accessible routes for concerns can help counter that tendency.
These measures do not guarantee fair decisions. They make it easier to notice whose experience is repeatedly absent.
7. A Project Can Learn Through Decisions That Change
For the repair project, a useful first step would be to pause the leaflet’s publication and discuss Samir’s concern.
The organisers could acknowledge that they had assumed he would welcome the portrayal. They could ask what he would prefer, revise the account with him if he wants to participate, and establish a clearer process for future publicity.
That resolves one issue.
A wider conversation might then ask how other decisions are made:
Who chooses workshop hours? Who can propose an activity? Who knows what funds are available? Who explains why a suggestion cannot be adopted?…
The group does not need to redesign everything at once.
It could begin with one bounded decision: participants might help plan the next three repair afternoons, with clear information about the venue, budget, and responsibilities.
Afterwards, the group could review what happened:
Did the arrangement make relevant knowledge available? Did participants understand their authority? Did the extra work fall repeatedly on the same people? Were decisions carried out? Could quieter participants affect the process?…
This review matters because shared influence brings difficulties as well as possibilities:
People disagree / Responsibilities can become unclear / Meetings can multiply without improving decisions / Participants may need time to develop unfamiliar skills…
The response is to examine and revise the arrangement.
Returning immediately to central control whenever participation becomes inconvenient would make the original invitation fragile.
Equally, retaining a confusing process merely because it is called participatory would not serve the people involved.
Care can learn when its organisation remains open to evidence from practice:
Belonging Includes the Possibility of Shaping What We Share
Samir’s place in the workshop began with an invitation.
It grew through shared activity.
A further change becomes possible when his perspective can influence how the project understands and organises itself.
He no longer appears only as someone for whom the project acts. He becomes one of the people with whom its future is developed.
That shift does not cancel the founders’ work or remove their responsibilities. It allows the relationships they helped create to inform what happens next.
Having a say means more than being asked for an opinion. It means knowing where influence is possible, being able to use it, and seeing a meaningful connection between participation and decisions.
For people receiving support, that connection can deepen belonging. For organisations, it can reveal possibilities and problems that goodwill alone would miss.
But sustaining it takes time, resources, skills, and dependable arrangements.
Coming next: Why Goodwill Needs Support
The next article explores what enables caring relationships and projects to endure—and why commitment becomes more trustworthy when the people providing care also receive practical support.
Next Reflection ➡️ Coming up


Leave a Reply