, ,

When a Functioning System Is Not Yet a Connected System

•

People gather above a river framed by roads, bridges and industrial buildings.

Functional Integration and Relational Integration

This article is part of the Human Connection Project, an interdisciplinary exploration of how people perceive, relate, belong, protect, and sometimes separate.

Section: Human Connection in Real Life
Series: From Analysis to Rebalancing
Reflection 4 of 5: When a Functioning System is Not Yet a Connected System

This article is part of the From Analysis to Rebalancing series, inspired by the Human Connection Project’s analysis of the 2026 Saxony-Anhalt election.
Although that case helped reveal how uncertainty, identity, protection, and reciprocal defence can deepen separation, the reflections in this series are intended to reach beyond one political event. They explore principles that may also be useful in conflicts between communities, institutions, political groups, and other human relationships where trust, belonging, and boundaries have become strained.

A society can function without yet feeling fully connected.

Its trains may run under one national system.
Its citizens may vote under the same constitution.
They may use the same currency, study under broadly shared educational structures, work within the same economy, and live under the same legal institutions.

From the outside, integration may appear largely complete.

Yet beneath that functioning surface, another question can remain:
Do people experience the system as truly theirs?
Do they feel represented within it?
Do they believe their experiences have become part of the shared story?
Do they feel that their losses were acknowledged alongside the benefits of change?
Do they see themselves as participants in shaping the future—or mainly as people who were expected to adapt to a future designed elsewhere?

These questions lead us toward a distinction that is useful far beyond Germany:
functional integration is not necessarily the same as relational integration.
The post-reunification history of Saxony-Anhalt offers an unusually revealing example.


1. Two meanings of “integrated”

When we say that two societies have been integrated, we often think first in structural terms:
Institutions have been joined.
Laws have been harmonized.
Administrative systems operate together.
Economic networks are connected.
Political authority is shared.
People can move freely across former boundaries…

This is what we might call functional integration.

Functional integration asks:
“Can the different parts now operate within the same system?”

It is enormously important. Without functioning institutions, infrastructure, legal order, economic coordination, public services and political stability, social life quickly becomes precarious.

But human beings do not relate to societies only as components within systems.
They also experience recognition, dignity, memory, identity, agency, trust, belonging and hope.

That creates a second dimension: relational integration.

Relational integration asks something different:
“Do the people within the system increasingly experience one another—and the system itself—as part of a genuinely shared social world?”

A country may therefore become functionally integrated much faster than it becomes relationally integrated. And when we confuse the two, we may congratulate ourselves on having completed a process that is still unfinished at another level.


2. German reunification: an extraordinary functional achievement

Seen institutionally, German reunification was remarkable.

Within an extremely short period, the political, legal, monetary, administrative and economic structures of the former German Democratic Republic were incorporated into the Federal Republic.
The constitutional route itself is significant. Reunification occurred through the accession of the former GDR territory under the then Article 23 of the Basic Law, rather than through the creation of an entirely new constitution for a newly founded German state. In practical terms, the existing West German constitutional system was extended eastward. (Federal Agency for Civic Education: “1990: Basic Law or a New Constitution?”)
New state institutions were established in the East. Saxony-Anhalt was reconstituted as a federal state, and on 14 October 1990, less than two weeks after German unity, voters elected its first post-reunification Landtag. (Federal Agency for Civic Education: 14 October 1990 state elections)

An immense amount had to happen almost simultaneously:
Administrative systems had to be reconstructed.
Property arrangements had to be clarified.
Enterprises suddenly had to function within a fundamentally different economic environment.
Infrastructure required modernization.
Political parties and institutions had to establish themselves under democratic conditions.
Legal and educational systems changed profoundly.

The economic transition was especially dramatic:
The Treuhandanstalt became responsible for privatizing, restructuring or closing a vast portion of the former East German state-owned economy.
By the time it was dissolved at the end of 1994, it had privatized or municipalized more than 12,000 companies and company units, while thousands of others had been closed.
(Federal Agency for Civic Education: The Birth of the Treuhand)

There is no need to minimize how difficult such a transformation was.
Nor should the enormous investments, infrastructure improvements, environmental restoration, political freedoms and expansion of opportunities following reunification be ignored.

Functional integration achieved a great deal.
But precisely because it achieved so much, another question becomes easier to overlook:
What was happening relationally while all these systems were being integrated functionally?


3. Saxony-Anhalt: when transformation enters everyday life

Saxony-Anhalt provides a particularly useful window because the transformation was not abstract there.
It entered factories, towns, families, biographies and expectations about the future.

Like much of the former GDR, the region had been shaped by large industrial enterprises and industrial communities. The transition to the market economy brought an exceptionally rapid contraction of industrial employment throughout eastern Germany.
Between 1989 and 1991 alone, employment in East German manufacturing fell from roughly 3.3 million to 1.7 million. The decline continued through the first half of the 1990s. (Federal Agency for Civic Education: Structural Change after Deindustrialization)
Across eastern Germany, employment overall fell from about 7.8 million people in 1989 to 5.8 million in 1993, while unemployment rose sharply. (Federal Agency for Civic Education: “Economy in Shock”)

Some enterprises survived and modernized.
Others were privatized.
Others were broken apart or closed.

Historians examining the Treuhand period have emphasized that the disappearance of enterprises also meant the disappearance of entire social and working environments. For many people, factories had been more than places of employment: they were connected to community networks, professional identity, social status and everyday life.
(Federal Agency for Civic Education: Twelve Theses on Economic Transformation and the Treuhand)

For an economist, a factory closing may appear as one component of structural adjustment.
For the person who worked there for twenty-five years, however, something else may disappear with it:
A profession.
A community.
A social position.
A network of relationships.
A sense of usefulness.
Perhaps even a piece of identity.

The distinction matters.

Systems experience restructuring as reallocation. Human beings experience restructuring biographically.

Sociological research on East German biographies after reunification likewise found that rapid systemic transformation destabilized careers and forced people to make major life adjustments under conditions for which their previous experience had not prepared them. (Acta Sociologica: “Transformation as Biographical Experience”)
And biographies do not update at the speed of legislation.


4. The Invisible Asymmetry of Reunification

There was another important feature of German reunification.
It was not the construction of an entirely new political system jointly designed from the ground up by two equal institutional partners.

The former East German states entered an already established Federal Republic whose Basic Law, economic order and major institutional structures continued.
This was not simply imposed against eastern wishes. The movement toward rapid unity enjoyed substantial support among East Germans during the extraordinary political developments of 1989–1990.

Nevertheless, the institutional form of reunification created an asymmetry.

Political sociologist Raj Kollmorgen describes reunification as an institutional incorporation of eastern Germany into the existing Federal Republic and argues that this process became important for the later development of distinct eastern German identities. (Federal Agency for Civic Education: “East German Identity/Identities?”)

For much of western Germany, reunification therefore meant something like: continuity plus expansion.
For many people in eastern Germany, it meant: freedom plus profound discontinuity.

Both can be true simultaneously.

This is one of the difficulties of collective memory: acknowledging the painful side of a transformation can easily be mistaken for denying its achievements.

But these are not mutually exclusive:
A person can be grateful for political freedom and still grieve the collapse of a professional world.
Someone can reject the authoritarianism of the GDR while feeling that portions of their own biography were subsequently treated dismissively.
One can value reunification while believing that aspects of the process produced inequalities.

Human experience rarely organizes itself into the clean categories demanded by political arguments.


5. Integration without Equal Participation

Relational integration becomes particularly difficult when people feel that they have entered a shared system without acquiring comparable influence over its direction.

This does not necessarily require deliberate exclusion.
Networks reproduce themselves:
Institutions recruit from familiar professional circles.
Existing credentials, cultural codes, educational pathways and relationships influence who moves upward.

During the post-reunification transformation, many professionals from western Germany moved into senior positions in eastern administration, universities, businesses, courts and other institutions.
There were understandable reasons for some of this transfer: the new system required expertise in institutions and legal structures that had not previously existed in the GDR, while questions of involvement with the former authoritarian state also affected personnel decisions.

Yet what begins as a transitional solution can leave long institutional traces.

More than three decades after reunification, people with eastern German biographies remain substantially underrepresented in leading positions across many sectors.
The Elitenmonitor found that eastern Germans held about 12.1 percent of the leadership positions examined in 2024, despite comprising roughly one fifth of Germany’s population. Their representation had risen from 10.9 percent in 2018, but significant disparities remained across sectors. (Federal Commissioner for Eastern Germany: Elitenmonitor 2024 results)
Researchers from Leipzig, Jena and Zittau/Görlitz continue to investigate the mechanisms behind this persistent underrepresentation. (Elitenmonitor research project)

This matters beyond questions of career fairness.

Representation carries a relational message.
It answers an implicit question:
Who is trusted to interpret the country, lead its institutions and define its future?

When people repeatedly see others making decisions about their region, describing its history, interpreting its grievances and occupying its most influential positions, functional membership can coexist with relational distance.

A person may legally belong to the same country while still feeling that the centre of that country lies somewhere else.


6. Demography Can Become Relational Memory

Few statistics capture Saxony-Anhalt’s post-reunification transformation as clearly as population change.

Between 1990 and 2024, Saxony-Anhalt lost approximately 26 percent of its population—the largest proportional decline among Germany’s federal states during that period. Across the eastern states excluding Berlin, the decline was about 16 percent. (German Federal Statistical Office: 35 Years of German Unity—Population Development)
Across eastern Germany as a whole, cumulative migration between East and West also mattered. From 1991 through 2024, around 1.2 million more people moved from East to West than in the opposite direction. (German Federal Statistical Office: Migration and Population since Reunification)

But statistics describe only one layer of the experience:
Population decline is lived socially.
A village loses young adults.
A school closes.
A family watches its children move hundreds of kilometres away.
A local business disappears.
Public services become harder to maintain.
An aging population remains while many younger and highly mobile people build their futures elsewhere.

Gradually, demographic change can acquire an emotional interpretation:
The future is happening somewhere else.

This does not mean that everyone in Saxony-Anhalt feels abandoned, nor that the region lacks successful communities, businesses, universities, investments or innovation.
It means that demographic change can alter the felt relationship between people and place.
When enough people leave, those who remain may experience not merely population decline but declining social confirmation:
Is this place still important?
Does the country see us?
Are our children expected to build their future here—or to leave in order to find it?

Those questions belong to relational integration.


7. Economic Convergence Can Be Real and Incomplete at the Same Time

Another temptation is to describe economic development as either success or failure.
Reality is more complicated.

Saxony-Anhalt today bears little resemblance economically or infrastructurally to the state that emerged from the transformation crisis of the early 1990s.
Much has been modernized.
Productivity has risen.
Businesses and new industries have developed.
Infrastructure has been renewed.

At the same time, important economic differences remain.

According to the Statistical Office of Saxony-Anhalt, average employee compensation in the state reached €49,516 in 2025, equivalent to approximately 84.8 percent of the German average. The gap had narrowed slightly, but remained substantial. (Statistical Office of Saxony-Anhalt: Employee Compensation 2025)

The important lesson is not simply that inequality persists.
It is that objective improvement and subjective disappointment can coexist.

Imagine being told repeatedly that your region has made enormous progress.
That may be statistically correct.
But if you simultaneously compare your salary, career possibilities, demographic prospects or influence with wealthier regions, you may also experience continuing disadvantage.

The two statements do not cancel each other:
Things have improved enormously.
And things are still unequal.

A mature society needs enough psychological and political space to hold both truths.


8. Why Gratitude Cannot Substitute for Belonging

This reveals a broader problem in social integration.

When one group has benefited significantly from reconstruction, transfers or institutional support, there can emerge an implicit expectation of gratitude:
Look how much has been invested.
Look how much has improved.
Look how much freedom and opportunity now exist.

These observations may be perfectly valid.
But gratitude cannot substitute for belonging.

The relational question is different.
People need to experience themselves not merely as recipients of a successful system, but increasingly as co-owners of it.

This is a crucial distinction.

A parent can provide everything materially necessary for a child while still failing to create emotional connection.
An organization can provide excellent working conditions while giving an employee little sense of voice or participation.
A state can provide infrastructure and legal rights while some citizens remain uncertain whether their histories, perspectives and contributions are genuinely respected.

Function matters enormously.
But function alone does not produce attachment.


9. Recognition does not mean endorsing every grievance

Here we need an important boundary:
Taking alienation seriously does not mean accepting every explanation attached to it.

A legitimate grievance can become connected to an inaccurate diagnosis.
Real economic insecurity can be redirected toward migrants.
A genuine feeling of cultural marginalization can become hostility toward minorities.
Distrust rooted in one experience can be generalized into conspiracy thinking.
Political actors can amplify resentment because resentment can be politically useful.

Understanding the origins of anger therefore does not require agreeing with every political expression of that anger.

This distinction is central to the Human Connection Project:
Understanding explains pathways. It does not automatically justify destinations.

Democratic societies still require ethical boundaries.
Human dignity remains a boundary.
Political violence remains a boundary.
Racism and dehumanization remain boundaries.
Constitutional principles remain boundaries.

But boundaries may become more sustainable when societies also understand the emotional, social and historical terrain through which people arrive at them.


10. Saxony-Anhalt Today: a Signal, Not a Simple Diagnosis

The continuing political differences between parts of eastern and western Germany have made these questions increasingly visible.

In the 6 September 2026 state election, the Alternative für Deutschland (AfD) received close to 44 percent of the vote and, according to the preliminary official allocation, won 39 of the 83 seats in Saxony-Anhalt’s Landtag.
Official Saxony-Anhalt election results
Official preliminary seat distribution

The Saxony-Anhalt Office for the Protection of the Constitution has classified the state AfD organization as a confirmed right-wing extremist movement since 2023, stating that its assessment found political agitation directed against essential principles of Germany’s free democratic constitutional order. (Saxony-Anhalt Ministry of the Interior: Office for the Protection of the Constitution classification)

These contemporary developments deserve attention.
But it would be far too simple to draw a straight causal line:
reunification hardship → contemporary voting behaviour.

More than thirty-five years have passed.
Generations have changed.
Migration, energy policy, economic pressures, war, geopolitical attitudes, demographic change, education, digital media, dissatisfaction with established parties and many other contemporary issues interact with historical experience.

Eastern Germany itself is neither politically nor socially homogeneous.
Historical research on post-reunification transformation therefore cautions against monocausal explanations.
The economic rupture of the 1990s is one part of a much larger social and political story. (Federal Agency for Civic Education: Structural Change after Deindustrialization)

Yet it would be equally simplistic to assume that historical experiences leave no residue simply because decades have passed.
Collective experience does not operate like a computer file that disappears when a generation changes.
Stories are transmitted.
Parents tell children which institutions they trusted and which disappointed them.
Communities remember which factories disappeared.
Regional identities absorb repeated public descriptions of who they are.
Political language then interacts with these existing sensitivities.

History does not dictate the present.
But it helps shape the terrain on which the present unfolds.


11. A Revealing Democratic Paradox

Recent research offers another important clue.

The Deutschland-Monitor 2025, a nationwide study of political and social attitudes, found that approximately 98 percent of respondents supported democracy as a form of government.
Yet satisfaction with how democracy actually functions was substantially lower.
Nationally, around 60 percent expressed satisfaction. In eastern Germany the figure was approximately 51 percent, although this represented an increase from 43 percent in 2023.
German Federal Government: Deutschland-Monitor 2025

The researchers also found relationships between democratic satisfaction and people’s perceptions of economic conditions, personal recognition and future prospects. (Friedrich Schiller University Jena: Deutschland-Monitor 2025 findings)

This distinction is extremely valuable.

A person can support democracy while distrusting particular institutions.
A citizen can want democratic government while believing that current democratic processes do not represent them adequately.
Someone can belong constitutionally while feeling distant relationally.

Once again:
functional participation and relational attachment are related, but they are not identical.
Political dissatisfaction therefore needs finer categories than simply for democracy or against democracy.


12. The Danger of Humiliation

There is another mechanism worth noticing.

Groups rarely become more integrated by being repeatedly told that their feelings demonstrate their inferiority.
If a community expresses anger and the response becomes primarily:
You are backward.
You are ungrateful.
You do not understand democracy.
You are the problem...
then even when criticism of particular beliefs or actions is justified, the form of communication may deepen the boundary society hopes to overcome.

Humiliation is a poor instrument of integration.
It activates defense.
And defensive identities can become harder, simpler and more oppositional.

The same mechanism can appear at many scales—from families and organizations to intergroup and political conflict.
When identity feels attacked, people may begin defending not merely a disputed belief but the group with which that belief has become associated.

This is why criticism sometimes has to perform two tasks simultaneously:
draw a clear boundary around unacceptable behaviour while leaving a path through which the person can return to relationship.

Without boundaries, connection becomes morally empty.
Without a path back, boundaries can become permanent separation.


13. What functional integration cannot manufacture

A government can build a railway. It cannot directly construct trust.
A parliament can pass a constitution. It cannot legislate belonging.
Economic policy can stimulate investment. It cannot command dignity.
Schools can teach a national curriculum. They cannot guarantee a shared historical memory.
Administrative systems can connect territories. They cannot automatically create mutual recognition.

This does not mean institutions are powerless.
On the contrary, institutions profoundly influence relational conditions:
Fair procedures matter.
Representation matters.
Economic opportunity matters.
Respectful public language matters.
Participation matters.
Local organizations matter.
Historical acknowledgement matters.

But relational integration emerges through accumulated experience.

People must repeatedly encounter evidence that:
my voice counts;
my dignity is protected;
my history can be discussed honestly;
the rules apply fairly;
people like me can participate meaningfully;
difference does not automatically make me an outsider;
and perhaps most importantly,
there is a credible place for me in the future.

That last point deserves particular attention.


14. Integration Ultimately Concerns the Future

Communities can often survive disagreements about the past when they believe they still share a future.
But when the future itself feels unequal, disagreements about history become more dangerous.

A common future cannot simply mean: You may join the future we have already defined.
That is closer to incorporation.

A deeper form of integration says: We will build a future in which all of us can participate in shaping what comes next.
This requires more than identical institutions.
It requires shared agency.

Shared agency does not mean every demand must be granted or every worldview considered equally compatible with democratic principles.
It means that people experience themselves as participants rather than merely objects of policy.
They are spoken with, not only spoken about.
Their region is not simply managed but represented.
Their history is neither romanticized nor dismissed.
Their contribution to the common society becomes visible.

Relational integration therefore involves not only belonging to something.
It involves having some genuine role in becoming what that something will be.


15. Perhaps Integration Is Not an Endpoint at all

This brings us back to the previous article in this series.

Winning is not the end.
Neither is reunification.
Neither is signing a peace agreement.
Neither is establishing a constitution.
Neither is joining two organizations.
Neither is restoring order after conflict.

These moments can close one phase while opening another.

Functional integration may actually mark the beginning of a more delicate task:
Once people share institutions, they must learn how to inhabit them together.
Once geographical borders disappear, psychological borders may become more visible.
Once conflict stops, unresolved grievances may surface.
Once a system becomes stable enough to function, people finally have enough space to ask whether they feel recognized within it.

That does not necessarily mean integration has failed.
It may mean integration has entered another stage.


16. From Integration toward Rebalancing

The lesson of Saxony-Anhalt should therefore not simply be: German reunification failed.
That would ignore enormous achievements and flatten a complicated history.
Nor should the lesson simply be: Reunification succeeded, therefore continuing alienation must be irrational.
That would confuse functional achievement with relational completion.

A more useful conclusion may be:

A functioning system creates conditions in which connection can grow. It does not guarantee that connection.

Relational integration requires continuing work.
It requires listening without surrendering judgment.
Acknowledging legitimate grievances without automatically accepting every explanation attached to them.
Protecting democratic and ethical boundaries without unnecessarily humiliating people outside the prevailing consensus.
Broadening participation.
Creating opportunities for meaningful contribution.
Allowing different memories to enter the shared historical story.
Building institutions that are not merely common administratively but increasingly experienced as common psychologically.
And repeatedly making a credible shared future visible—not merely promising one.


17. Connection Does Not Require Sameness

Perhaps one of the deepest mistakes is believing that successful integration should eventually erase difference.

East and West do not need to become psychologically identical.
Different regions need not remember history identically.
Different generations need not interpret transformation in exactly the same way.

Connection does not require a single story.
It requires a social space large enough for multiple stories to coexist without destroying the possibility of a shared future.

This is why relational integration should not be understood as absorption.
It is closer to rebalancing.
The relationship continually adjusts as histories, identities, inequalities, expectations and circumstances change.

Some differences may gradually fade.
Others may remain.
Some wounds may heal.
Others may become part of collective memory.

The goal is not to erase all distinction.
The goal is to prevent distinction from hardening into permanent relational separation.


When the System Works, Ask the Next Question

Saxony-Anhalt’s post-reunification history gives us an unusually clear lesson.

A society can possess functioning democratic institutions, modern infrastructure, common laws, extensive economic integration and shared formal citizenship—and still contain unresolved questions of recognition, representation, trust, identity and belonging.

Those questions are not peripheral to the system.
Over time, they influence how people relate to the system itself.

Perhaps, then, after every major conflict, transition or institutional integration, we should ask two different questions.

The first is: Does the new system work?
But eventually we must ask another: Are the people within it learning to experience this system—and one another—as genuinely shared?

The first question is about function.
The second is about relationship.
Stable societies need both.

And perhaps one of the most important lessons of human connection is that building the structure is often faster than building the relationship capable of inhabiting it.

The structure can sometimes be created by law.
The relationship must be created through experience.
Again and again.
Over time.
And together.


Where This Leads

If functional integration does not automatically produce relational integration, then the next question is unavoidable:
What actually helps people rebuild relationship without abandoning necessary boundaries?

Recognizing grievance is not the same as agreeing with every claim.
Listening does not require surrendering judgment.
Trying to understand someone does not require accepting racism, dehumanization, violence, authoritarianism or attacks on democratic principles.

At the same time, simply drawing harder boundaries cannot by itself produce trust, belonging or shared agency.

This is where the next stage of the Human Connection Project begins.

Article 5 will move from diagnosis toward practice. It will explore what deliberate relational repair may require:
listening to understand rather than defeat;
communicating honestly without humiliation;
acknowledging legitimate grievances;
rebuilding trust through repeated experience;
distinguishing understanding from endorsement;
retaining ethical and democratic boundaries;
creating genuinely shared institutions and practices;
and making a credible common future possible.

The question will no longer be merely: Why does separation persist?
It will become:

How can people remain different, maintain necessary boundaries, and still rebuild enough relationship to inhabit a future together?


Sources & Further Reading

Federal Agency for Civic Education (bpb), “1990: Basic Law or a New Constitution?” — background on the constitutional path through which German reunification occurred and the debate between accession under Article 23 and drafting a new constitution. Read the article

Federal Agency for Civic Education (bpb), “Treuhandanstalt and Economic Transformation” — a detailed overview of privatization, restructuring, controversy and the social consequences of the transformation of the East German economy. Read the article

Joachim Ragnitz, “Structural Change after Deindustrialization,” bpb — economic analysis of the collapse and later restructuring of East German industry following reunification. Read the article

Marcus Böick, “Twelve Theses on Economic Transformation and the Treuhand,” bpb — examines the Treuhand not only economically but also through its continuing role in East German memory and interpretations of the transformation period. Read the article

Raj Kollmorgen, “East German Identity/Identities?”, bpb — explores how the experience and structure of reunification contributed to the continuing development of eastern German identity. Read the article

Elitenmonitor / Universities of Leipzig, Jena and Zittau-Görlitz — long-term empirical research into the continuing underrepresentation of eastern Germans in leading positions across politics, administration, business, academia, the judiciary, media and other sectors. Explore the research project

German Federal Statistical Office, “35 Years of German Unity” — comparative demographic data showing population development in eastern and western Germany since 1990, including Saxony-Anhalt’s approximately 26 percent population decline. Explore the statistics

Statistical Office of Saxony-Anhalt, Employee Compensation 2025 — current figures on employee compensation and the remaining gap between Saxony-Anhalt and the German national average. Read the statistical release

Deutschland-Monitor 2025 — nationwide research on democracy, political attitudes, recognition, social change and differences between eastern and western Germany. German Federal Government summary

Official results of the 2026 Saxony-Anhalt state election — preliminary state-level results and seat distribution for the election held on 6 September 2026. Saxony-Anhalt Statistical Office election results

Leave a Reply