, , ,

Before We Cast the Stone: Germany’s Political Divide After the 2026 State Elections

•

Graphite drawing of an open hand above a stone resting on a table. Text reads “Before We Cast the Stone” and “Germany’s Divide.”

In the Gospel of John, Jesus responds to a group ready to condemn a woman by asking who among them is without sin. His words turn the question back on those making the accusation. What would change if we brought that same willingness to examine ourselves into political debate?

In this Human Connection Project video, I look at Germany’s political divisions after the September 2026 state elections in Saxony-Anhalt and Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania. What were voters trying to protect? When does refusing political cooperation serve a legitimate purpose, and what responsibilities remain across that boundary? What would those in government need to change for people to have reason to trust them again?

The video also examines two fatal traffic cases, in Frankfurt and Eilenburg, to ask how courts explain judgments, how journalists report them, and how political loyalties can shape our reactions. Would we judge the same conduct by the same standards if the person involved came from a different background? Can we take victims’ losses seriously, consider the possibility of rehabilitation, and still ask whether a sentence is proportionate?

In this video, I explore separation at the level of society, through political divisions, public institutions, and the ways groups come to distrust one another. The thirteen-part Understanding Separation series brings those questions into everyday relationships. If you’d like to explore why we pull away from one another, when distance protects us, and what makes repair possible, you can read the series on this website.

The video’s political reporting reflects information available on the morning of 14 November 2026.


Narration: Before We Cast the Stone

Germany, political division, and shared responsibility

Chapter 1 — Before we cast the stone

“Let any one of you who is without sin be the first to throw a stone at her.”

In the Gospel of John, Jesus speaks these words when a woman accused of adultery is brought before him. Her accusers ask whether she should be stoned. His response turns their attention toward themselves. One by one, they leave.

The question reaches beyond that moment. When we condemn someone else, how carefully have we examined the standards we apply to ourselves?

This is a useful starting point for looking at Germany’s political divisions. We will examine political choices, the concerns behind them, and the responsibilities that remain after an election. Throughout, the invitation is to include ourselves in the scrutiny we direct toward others.

We can believe a policy is harmful and explain why. We can demand accountability for misconduct. Our criticism becomes more credible when we are also prepared to acknowledge errors within our preferred party, our community, or our own understanding. Otherwise, we risk asking others to practise a responsibility from which we quietly excuse ourselves.

This question connects with the research behind the thirteen-part series Understanding Separation. That series examined what happens when people become less willing to understand one another, adjust to legitimate concerns, cooperate, or consider repair.

We began by distinguishing different forms of distance. Refusal can protect safety, dignity, or limited resources. It can also preserve an unfair advantage or prevent another person from questioning a decision.

We then examined consequences. When cooperation becomes restricted, whose work increases? Whose concerns disappear from decisions? Who retains the freedom to withdraw, and who must continue living with the effects?

Only then did we consider repair. An invitation to reconnect carries little weight if the conditions that made withdrawal reasonable remain unchanged. Trust needs something to rest on. Reliable conduct, fairer arrangements, or evidence that a concern can influence what happens next can give people a reason to reconsider.

These questions become especially important in politics, where decisions affect people who cannot simply leave the relationship. Citizens continue sharing institutions, infrastructure, and public resources despite profound disagreement. Governments exercise authority over supporters and opponents alike. Their responsibilities extend to people who distrust them.

Our task is to examine Germany’s divisions with enough humility to learn and enough precision to hold people accountable. Nobody’s preferred position should place them beyond examination, and responsibility grows with the power a person or institution holds.

Chapter 2 — What the elections reveal

In Saxony-Anhalt’s September 2026 state election, the Alternative for Germany, or AfD, received 43.8 percent of the vote and thirty-nine of the state parliament’s eighty-three seats. It became the largest party but fell short of a parliamentary majority.

Two weeks later, AfD also finished first in Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania, receiving 38.2 percent and thirty-two of seventy-one seats. Again, it fell short of a majority of its own.

The two elections produced different paths toward a government. In the reporting available through November fourteenth, government formation in Saxony-Anhalt remained unresolved. In Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania, the Social Democrats, the Left Party, and the Greens had negotiated a coalition agreement. The Left approved it on November thirteenth, with the Social Democrats and the Greens scheduled to vote at their party conferences the following day.

What can we learn from an election result? It records a collective outcome produced by individual choices. Some voters may strongly support a party’s programme. Others may prioritize a particular issue, prefer its candidates, reject the alternatives, or want to punish previous failures. Several reasons can coexist.

That makes it risky to describe an entire electorate as a protest movement, or as a community united around every position its chosen party holds. Votes establish support. Claims about causes and solutions still require evidence.

Consider a concern about rising living costs. The difficulty of paying a bill is an experience. A judgment about which policy caused the rise is an explanation. Confidence that a particular party can reverse it is a further judgment. Each deserves examination on its own terms.

The same applies to opponents of AfD. Concern about a party’s conduct or proposals needs to be assessed through specific evidence. The party’s conduct and the reasons each voter supported it are separate questions.

That distinction matters when parties decide what cooperation they will refuse. Listening seriously to a voter, supporting a particular parliamentary proposal, and entering a governing coalition involve different commitments. Each decision raises a question about what the boundary protects and which responsibilities continue on both sides of it.

Chapter 3 — Different concerns, shared vulnerabilities

In Saxony-Anhalt, Infratest dimap’s election survey identified social security as the most frequently named decisive issue among voters overall. Peace in Europe, the economy, internal security, education, and migration also appeared among their priorities. Responses differed across party supporters.

Security can mean a reliable income, access to public services, physical safety, or confidence in the future of a familiar way of life. These concerns can overlap, but they require different kinds of evidence and different responses.

For AfD supporters surveyed in the state, worries about prices and maintaining living standards appeared alongside strong concerns about immigration and cultural change. That tells us the anxieties can coexist. Which conditions are driving each concern, and what would actually improve them?

People also want evidence that their experience enters public decisions. Being addressed during an election campaign can feel very different from being able to influence what happens afterward. When we ask others to acknowledge our insecurity, are we willing to consider the insecurity our preferred response may create?

Reporting before the Saxony-Anhalt election documented concerns among people with migration backgrounds about their safety, belonging, and future. Those accounts are part of the situation. So are concerns among residents who feel that pressures on their communities have been overlooked. Each deserves attention, and claims about the causes or consequences of those pressures deserve checking.

The categories can mislead us. People with migration backgrounds also worry about wages, schools, housing, crime, and public finances. They hold different political views. Long-established residents likewise differ in their experiences and priorities. Describing these populations as two coherent sides can reproduce the separation we are trying to understand.

Protecting fair participation and resisting intimidation are serious responsibilities. How those responsibilities are exercised remains open to scrutiny. A person can defend an important principle while speaking carelessly about people whose support they hope to regain. Similarly, identifying an overlooked grievance is a constructive contribution. The person identifying it still needs to explain how their remedy would work and who would bear its costs.

It is relatively easy to agree that other people should show humility. The harder task is to notice whether we allow our own group explanations and exceptions that we deny to opponents. Do we ask for patience with our own mistakes while interpreting every mistake elsewhere as proof of bad faith?

Let’s apply that question to the parties themselves: What do they ask of others, what do they promise, and how do they respond when those same demands are turned toward them?

Chapter 4 — Applying the same standards to political parties

A political party asks us to trust its account of what has gone wrong and its promise of what could improve. Recognizing a problem is a contribution. The proposed response must still be judged by what it can achieve, how it treats people, and what costs it creates.

Consider AfD. Many respondents in the election surveys associated the party with understanding their worries. Established parties should examine why their own explanations and actions failed to earn comparable confidence among those voters. AfD, in turn, should explain how its policies would improve the conditions it has called attention to.

Deutsche Welle’s examination of AfD’s programme in Saxony-Anhalt reported proposals to end state funding for integration programmes and to exclude children without permanent residency from regular schools. These were proposals made during the election campaign.

If the objective is a society in which people communicate, work, and participate more effectively, how would reducing opportunities for integration contribute to it? What educational arrangements would replace those being restricted? What would the change mean for the children, their families, and the schools expected to carry it out?

Our research directs attention to the relationship between protection and transferred burdens. A measure may promise relief to one group while making participation harder for another. A convincing justification must address both effects.

Established parties face an equally necessary examination of their own responsibilities. In Saxony-Anhalt, the CDU’s electoral defeat raises questions about its governing record and its response to dissatisfaction. Criticism of an opponent can be warranted, and the CDU still owes voters an account of what it delivered and where results fell short.

In November, CDU state leader Sven Schulze said his party would assess AfD proposals individually according to whether they benefited the state. Critics within the CDU warned that this approach could help sustain an AfD minority government.

Assessing a proposal’s substance can protect public decisions from becoming automatic contests of party identity. But parties also need to consider whether supporting that proposal would help another party gain power or pursue other policies they have good reasons to oppose.

What would the proposal accomplish? What commitments would supporting it create? If a party refuses cooperation, what is that refusal meant to protect, and how will it fulfil its responsibilities to voters in the meantime?

The Social Democrats, Greens, and Left Party also need to demonstrate how their commitments translate into workable arrangements. In Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania, their negotiated coalition programme included hospital investment, continued free childcare, and measures intended to improve education. These are commitments directed toward everyday needs. The reporting also described a projected financing gap and warnings from the state audit office.

Protecting services is a meaningful objective. Credibility depends on showing how staffing, funding, and priorities will support it. Budget constraints deserve serious attention, and so do the costs of leaving needs unmet. The parties should explain how they plan to weigh those choices and who will be affected.

Opposition parties face similar demands. The BSW’s small parliamentary group occupies a consequential position in Saxony-Anhalt’s government formation. Its choices about support or abstention may affect which government becomes possible. Distance from a formal coalition leaves it answerable for the foreseeable effects of its decisions.

Across these cases, the standard remains consistent: What concern does the party recognize? What evidence supports its proposal? Who bears the costs? And what will the party acknowledge if its judgment proves mistaken?

Chapter 5 — How society participates in separation

Political responsibility extends beyond party leadership. Citizens, journalists, campaigners, and community organizations also influence which concerns receive attention and how disagreement is expressed. Their powers differ. A voter has a different reach from a national broadcaster and a different authority from a government.

Still, each of us can examine the standards we apply. One useful test is whether we can describe an opposing concern accurately before criticizing the response attached to it. Can we acknowledge pressure on local services while questioning a claim about its causes? Can we take fears of discrimination seriously and examine what a disputed policy would actually do?

For journalists and commentators, responsibility begins with investigating the situation thoroughly. Before reporting, analyzing, or offering an opinion, they need enough reliable background information to understand the issue, consider different perspectives, and examine evidence that might challenge their first impression.

Different perspectives deserve consideration, but their claims still need to be checked against the evidence. Where information is incomplete or disputed, that uncertainty should remain visible. This groundwork helps audiences distinguish what is established, what remains uncertain, and what is the journalist’s or commentator’s interpretation.

Scrutiny also requires follow-through. Reporting an accusation gives it public visibility. Establishing whether it is supported, correcting errors, and examining later developments are part of making that visibility useful.

For citizens, the equivalent question concerns what we repeat and defend: Are we willing to check a claim that supports our position? When it proves inaccurate, do we correct it with the same willingness with which we first shared it?

Campaign groups and civil society organizations can bring neglected experiences into public view. Their contribution can be assessed through the evidence they uncover and the opportunities for participation they create. A cause we consider just still deserves accurate reporting, and the people an advocate represents deserve to be heard even when the advocate makes a mistake.

The same care is necessary when discussing majority and minority communities. People differ in conduct, circumstances, influence, and political commitments. Collective blame makes those differences harder to see. It asks individuals to answer for people they may never have supported, while the specific decisions and responsible actors disappear into a broad category.

Here, the invitation to put down the stone becomes practical. We can name the action, examine its consequences, and ask the responsible person or institution to answer for it. We can maintain boundaries where the reasons for them remain and recognize credible change when it occurs.

Chapter 6 — From accusation to responsibility

Once we identify a problem, responsibility becomes concrete: Who had the authority to act? What did they know? What did they do? And what would show that their response had made a difference?

In Germany, some decisions belong to municipalities, others to state or federal authorities, and some involve European institutions. When responsibility is shared, people need to know who can act and how the institutions involved will work together. A complaint passed from one office to another can leave people wondering whether raising it was worth the effort.

A failure in a public service may begin a loss of confidence. Unanswered complaints or repeated promises can give people further reasons to withdraw their trust, even after the original problem starts to improve.

The OECD’s 2026 report, based on survey responses collected in Germany in 2025, found a large gap in trust in the federal government between people who felt they had a political voice and those who felt they did not. The survey predates the elections discussed in this video. It gives us a reason to ask what opportunities people have to influence decisions between elections.

Listening should leave an observable trace: What did an authority hear? What did it investigate? Which decisions changed as a result? When a request could not be accepted, did the people affected receive a clear explanation and an opportunity to challenge it?

These questions become especially demanding when we turn to justice. Germany’s Basic Law establishes equality before the law. Across social classes and backgrounds, people should be able to expect faithful enforcement, a fair hearing, and judgments based on evidence. Can people exercise those protections in practice, including when they lack money or connections?

In Frankfurt, two twenty-three-year-old twin brothers were killed in July 2025 when a car struck their E-scooter. Their friend survived with life-changing injuries. In September 2026, the court sentenced the driver to three years in prison. His convictions included two counts of negligent homicide and attempted murder by omission concerning the survivor. The judgment was still open to challenge when reported.

Two young men died. Their friend will live with the injuries. How did the court arrive at three years? How did it weigh the seriousness of the harm against the conduct and intent it could establish?

Court reporting described the judges’ consideration of accident shock, remorse, and efforts to compensate the people harmed. The court also found that the evidence did not show the driver was still under the influence of nitrous oxide at the time of the crash. These details help us understand the judgment and assess whether its reasons are convincing.

When a sentence strikes people as too light, what happens to their confidence that the law will protect them? Could some young people take away the impression that they can disregard the rules and other people’s safety without facing serious consequences? What combination of enforcement, driving restrictions, supervision, and rehabilitation would make responsibility real and reduce the chance of further harm?

And in a case involving a person with an immigrant background, could perceived leniency deepen hostility toward other people who had nothing to do with the offence? What role do the judgment, the way it is reported, and the way political figures talk about it play in that reaction?

Those questions deserve to be followed over time. A headline or an immediate public reaction tells us little about whether young drivers change their behaviour, whether trust recovers, or whether hostility spreads. Each question requires its own evidence.

The Eilenburg case shows how much turns on the account people hear. Four people died in a crash in March 2023. In February 2025, the driver received three and a half years of youth imprisonment. He remained at liberty pending possible further proceedings. A headline that said he “remained free” could leave readers with the impression that the court had imposed no prison term.

The German Press Council publicly reprimanded the report. It found the description of the youth proceedings as a secret trial misleading and judged the prominent reference to the driver’s nationality unjustified in that report. The council warned that emphasizing it could fuel prejudice against a minority.

The sensitivity of immigration makes consistency especially important: Would we treat the same proven conduct as equally serious if the driver came from a different background? Would we insist on the same legal protections for an accused person we disliked? Would the victims receive the same attention if their story were less useful to our political argument?

The same examination applies to wealth. When a court considers compensation, how does it weigh what a person has done to make amends against what they were financially able to do? What would count as a comparable effort from someone with far fewer resources? German sentencing law recognizes both economic circumstances and efforts to repair harm as relevant considerations.

Care includes recognizing the losses borne by victims and families, the public’s need for protection, and the possibility that a person who has caused harm can change. Courts must apply the law faithfully. Journalists must understand the proceedings before interpreting them. Political leaders must answer for their own claims and proposals, especially when a case is already dividing public opinion.

Chapter 7 — Can those in power examine themselves?

At the beginning, Jesus’s words invited us to examine ourselves before casting a stone. That invitation reaches the people currently governing Germany.

In November 2026, only eleven percent of respondents in the ARD DeutschlandTrend survey said they were satisfied with the federal government’s work. The figure was slightly higher than in October, and dissatisfaction remained widespread even among supporters of the governing parties. The survey measured satisfaction with government performance. It gives us a reason to ask how seriously leaders have examined the sources of that dissatisfaction.

Have they investigated why so many people judge their work poorly? Can they identify where their own decisions contributed to the problem? Have they looked closely at arrangements they have defended and asked who benefits, who carries the cost, and whose experience they may have overlooked?

There have been acknowledgments. Chancellor Friedrich Merz admitted shortcomings in explaining the coalition’s reforms. After the September elections, he also acknowledged that federal politics and his own leadership had played a role in his party’s losses. SPD leaders called for changes to the substance of some reforms as well as to their presentation.

What has changed as a result? Which decisions have been reopened? Where have leaders named a mistake, explained who bore its consequences, and taken steps to correct it?

A government can spend a great deal of time explaining a decision and still leave its underlying assumptions unexamined. When criticism comes from voters, the opposition, or even from within the governing coalition, can leaders recognize that it may expose a real problem? When doubts arise about a policy they have publicly defended, are they prepared to acknowledge those doubts? How much does the fear of losing face influence the decision to hold course?

Keeping a coalition together can provide the stability needed to govern. What public purpose is that stability serving, and how can citizens judge it? When keeping office and correcting a failing policy pull in different directions, which priority shows up in the government’s actions?

Some sound decisions will remain unpopular. The government can defend them by explaining the evidence and the trade-offs, and by stating what would lead it to revise them. If citizens are asked to reconsider their judgment of the government, they should also be able to see how the government reconsiders its own.

The same scrutiny belongs to opposition parties that seek power. The government bears a particular responsibility today because it already has authority over decisions, funding, and administration. Citizens can check a claim before repeating it or acknowledge a valid criticism. Public officials can change the conditions that gave rise to the complaint.

People may still disagree about migration, public spending, or which parties should work together. Progress can be seen in what becomes possible despite those disagreements. A concern can be heard and investigated. A mistake can be corrected openly. People can cooperate where they have a shared task and maintain boundaries where they have good reasons to do so.

So before asking whether the other side is willing to change, each of us has a question to answer: What criticism are we willing to take seriously when it is directed at us, and what would we do differently if it turned out to be right?

In this video, we’ve looked at separation on the scale of a society, through political divisions, public institutions, and the ways groups come to distrust one another. In my Understanding Separation series, I bring those questions into everyday life. What happens when we pull away from someone? When does distance protect us? And what makes it possible to rebuild trust?

If you’d like to explore what separation looks like in our ordinary relationships, you can read the thirteen-part series here.


References

Leave a Reply