,

Belonging Without Needing an Enemy

•

People of different ages and backgrounds build pathways and tend a shared circular garden in a warm, open landscape.

How Groups Can Build Protection, Purpose, and Shared Stability That Survive Success

This article is part of the Human Connection Project, an interdisciplinary exploration of how people perceive, relate, belong, protect, and sometimes separate.

Area: Relationships, Belonging, and Separation
Series: Belonging, Enemies, and Political Division
Article 9 of 9: Belonging Without Needing an Enemy
Previous articles: How an Institution Grows a Purpose
Companion guide: Key Concepts in Belonging, Conflict, and Stability

The previous article imagined an institution as something that grows.

It may begin with an early possibility: a problem someone wants to solve, a value people want to protect, or a form of life they hope to make possible. With practice, planning, confidence, accountability, and maintenance, that possibility can develop into a dependable social capacity.

But an institution does not grow alone.

People must decide that its purpose matters. They must invest attention, labor, trust, and identity in it. They must feel that participating connects them to something larger than themselves.

This is where belonging enters.

An enemy can make belonging appear quickly. It tells people who they are, what threatens them, why they must stay together, and what action is required. It can transform uncertainty into clarity and isolation into solidarity.

Yet the resulting stability is dependent.

If the group needs another population to remain dangerous, corrupt, impure, or morally irredeemable, then its unity cannot safely survive peace, improvement, or successful reform.

This final article therefore turns from diagnosis toward construction.

It does not argue that every conflict is a misunderstanding, that every opponent is equally responsible, or that people should abandon boundaries in the face of real harm. Comparison is not equivalence. Understanding a relationship does not erase differences in conduct, power, or responsibility.

The question is more demanding:

How can people feel protected, recognized, and politically significant without needing another group to remain dangerous?


1. Why an Enemy Can Organize Belonging So Quickly

An enemy-centered story performs several social and psychological tasks at once.

  • It creates clarity.
    Many causes of insecurity—economic change, weak administration, cultural transition, demographic pressure, unequal power, technological disruption, personal loss, …—can be gathered into one explanation.
  • It creates recognition.
    A person who felt ignored is told that the injury was real, that others experienced it too, and that the group understands.
  • It creates a boundary.
    Members learn who belongs, who does not, and what qualities a loyal person is expected to display.
  • It creates urgency.
    Ordinary disagreement becomes a struggle in which hesitation appears dangerous.
  • It creates agency.
    Fear and helplessness can be converted into protest, resistance, voting, organizing, or collective defiance.

Research helps explain why this mechanism is powerful. A recent meta-analysis of intergroup competition and cooperation found that competition between groups can increase cooperation within them. A shared external opponent can make internal coordination feel more necessary and rewarding.

But cohesion does not prove that the group’s explanation is accurate.
It does not prove that the opponent deserves the role assigned to it.
It does not show that the resulting unity can support a healthy society.

The speed with which an enemy creates belonging is one of its political advantages. The costs often appear later.


2. When Internal Stability Disrupts the Shared World

A group may feel calmer and more coherent while the society around it becomes less stable.
Members trust one another more because they trust outsiders less.
They gain confidence because uncertainty has been attached to a human cause.
They experience moral clarity because mixed evidence has been compressed into a conflict between innocence and danger.
They feel protected because the group has become more vigilant, more closed, and more prepared to exclude.

This is disruptive stability.

It is not the absence of stability. It is stability achieved locally by disturbing the relationships and institutions on which wider shared life depends.

The concept applies beyond any single ideology:
A nationalist movement may stabilize itself by portraying migrants or minorities as permanent threats.
A movement against concentrated power may stabilize itself by treating every wealthy person, official, or business as part of one malicious bloc.
An institution may protect its internal reputation by locating every failure in hostile critics.
A community may preserve harmony by excluding members who name unresolved harm.

These cases are not politically or morally equivalent. Their targets, power relations, remedies, and consequences differ.

What they share is a structural question:

Is the group addressing a specific problem, or has the continued existence of an enemy become necessary to its own coherence?


3. Belonging Needs a Positive Center

Removing an enemy from a group’s story can leave an unexpected emptiness.
Members may agree about what they reject but not about what they want to maintain together.

A positive center is not simply a hopeful slogan.
Words such as community, justice, freedom, tradition, solidarity, and democracy can unite people emotionally while concealing incompatible meanings.

A purpose becomes socially real when it can answer practical questions:

  • Who should benefit from our existence?
  • What capacity are we trying to build?
  • What do members do together?
  • How will responsibility be shared?
  • How will disagreement be handled?
  • How will we know whether conditions are improving?
  • What will still hold us together if the original crisis recedes?

Article 8 described this as the growth of an institution’s purpose. An early possibility becomes a dependable capacity through repeated practice.

The same is true of belonging.

People do not become attached only to an abstract value. They become attached to the experience of practicing it together.
A neighborhood develops belonging by caring for shared spaces, welcoming new residents, solving local problems, and transmitting memories.
A political party develops belonging by helping people participate, preparing members for public responsibility, translating values into workable policy, and remaining present between elections.
A democratic society develops belonging by making equal membership visible through law, public institutions, cultural life, and ordinary encounters.

The alternative to enemy-dependent belonging is therefore not belonging without distinction.
It is belonging organized around a shared social practice.


4. Recognition Must Not Make Grievance Permanent

Groups often form around a real experience of injury:
Workers lose security. A region loses influence. A minority faces discrimination. Citizens experience institutional failure. A community feels that rapid change occurred without its participation.

Telling people to move on before the injury has been recognized rarely creates reconciliation. It may deepen the belief that only a more confrontational movement is willing to listen.

Recognition is therefore necessary.
But recognition can take two different directions.

The first says:
What happened matters. Let us understand it carefully, identify responsibility, repair what can be repaired, and build greater capacity for the future.

The second says:
What happened reveals who our enemies truly are. We must keep the injury central so that we never become weak again.

The first turns pain toward authorship.
The second turns pain toward permanent mobilization.

This distinction protects two truths at once:

  • recognizing pain does not require endorsing every explanation of blame;
  • questioning an enemy story does not require denying the original pain.

Rebalancing begins by separating the experience from the totalizing interpretation attached to it:
What was lost?
Which decisions contributed?
Who possessed meaningful power?
Which consequences were intended, foreseeable, preventable, or still repairable?
Which parts of the story are supported by evidence, and which parts were later added to make the conflict morally complete?

Specific recognition can lead to action.
Generalized grievance requires an indefinitely guilty category.


5. Shared Efficacy Can Replace Shared Helplessness

An enemy story does not offer only blame. It also offers the feeling that people can finally act together.

Any constructive alternative must preserve that sense of agency.

Psychologists use the term collective efficacy for a group’s shared belief that it can organize and carry out action toward a goal. Research on collective efficacy emphasizes that this is not merely the sum of individual confidence. It emerges through relationships, shared expectations, coordination, and experience. A useful interdisciplinary review describes collective efficacy as a collective perception produced through social processes.

Groups develop this belief when they experience themselves succeeding together.

They secure a safer crossing near a school.
They create a tenant association.
They improve access to a local service.
They help new residents learn how institutions work.
They protect someone facing discrimination.
They negotiate a policy change and see a measurable result…

These acts may appear less dramatic than defeating an enemy. But they create a more durable message:
We matter because we can care for and change part of our shared world.

Specific objectives are important. A meta-analysis of goal setting in groups found that specific, difficult group goals produced substantially better performance than vague goals.

This does not mean that every social purpose should be reduced to a target or metric. It means that ambition becomes credible when people can connect values to actions, responsibilities, and visible learning.

Collective efficacy gives belonging a future-facing foundation.
The group no longer needs helplessness to prove why it must exist.


6. Belonging Is Built Through Body, Meaning, and Culture

The three lenses of the Human Connection Project help clarify why positive purpose must be lived rather than merely announced.

Through the neuroscience lens

Threat attracts attention and prepares the body for protection. Repeated signals of danger can make vigilance feel responsible and calm feel naïve.

A constructive group therefore needs repeated experiences of safety, predictability, coordination, and successful action. People must encounter evidence that cooperation works and that uncertainty does not always lead to abandonment.

Through the psychology lens

Belonging supports identity, recognition, agency, and self-worth. If a group offers these only through opposition, members may experience any softening of conflict as a loss of self.

A healthier group gives members valued roles that do not depend on anger: listener, organizer, caregiver, mediator, teacher, planner, builder, protector, critic, or learner.

Through the anthropology lens

Belonging is carried through practices, symbols, stories, places, rituals, and shared memory. A group cannot replace an enemy story only with an administrative plan.

It needs ways to remember, gather, celebrate, mourn, welcome, disagree, and transmit responsibility.

This is why facts alone rarely dissolve enemy-dependent belonging.
The enemy may be performing biological, psychological, and cultural functions simultaneously.

The alternative must be capable of doing the same—without requiring dehumanization.


7. Boundaries Are Part of Belonging

Belonging without an enemy does not mean belonging without boundaries.

Every group must decide:

  • what conduct it will accept;
  • what responsibilities members carry;
  • how resources will be shared;
  • how decisions will be made;
  • and what happens when someone causes harm.

A democracy must protect equal rights and the constitutional order.
A party may refuse cooperation with an organization whose proposals violate its principles.
A community may exclude a person from a role after serious misconduct.
An institution may enforce professional standards even when doing so creates conflict.

The crucial distinction lies in what the boundary attaches to.

A protective boundary says:
This act, rule, proposal, or pattern of conduct is incompatible with the conditions we must protect.

An enemy boundary says:
This kind of person is inherently incompatible with us.

Protective boundaries should be as specific as the danger permits. They should be evidence-based, proportionate, consistently applied, and open to review.

Where possible, they should also preserve a dignified path back.
That path may require changed conduct, accountability, restitution, or renewed commitment. It does not require forgetting the harm.

It means that the group’s identity is not organized around permanent social contamination.
Some harms make renewed relationship impossible or unsafe. No general framework should pressure victims to restore contact with an abuser or require democratic institutions to treat anti-democratic conduct as ordinary disagreement.

But even when reconciliation is unavailable, responsibility can remain specific.
Protection does not require hatred to become a social inheritance.


8. A Larger “We” Must Not Erase Smaller Identities

One response to political division is to emphasize a common identity:
Whatever our differences, we are all members of the same community.

This can reduce the distance between groups. The Common Ingroup Identity Model proposes that people may show less bias when former out-group members are understood as part of a more inclusive “we.”

Yet common identity can also become a demand for assimilation.
If the majority defines what the larger “we” looks like, minorities may be invited to belong only by making their difference less visible. A declaration that “we are all the same” can also hide unequal treatment.

Research on dual identity offers a more careful possibility. People can identify with a shared political community while retaining meaningful subgroup identities. Studies of dual identity emphasize its potential to connect minority and majority members without requiring distinctiveness to disappear, while also warning that the effect depends on context and boundary conditions. A useful open review discusses both the benefits and limits of dual identity.

The goal is not sameness.
It is a shared structure in which difference does not automatically imply danger or lesser membership.

A person can be eastern German and German.
Muslim and German.
Economically conservative and committed to equal citizenship.
Socialist and part of a plural democracy.
Newly arrived and increasingly responsible for the place in which they now live.

The larger “we” becomes credible when people do not have to surrender every smaller “we” in order to enter it.


9. Contact Helps Most When the Relationship Is Designed Carefully

It is tempting to think that divided people simply need to meet.
Contact can help, but not every encounter does.

A large meta-analysis of 515 studies found that intergroup contact typically reduced prejudice across many settings. Later reviews have emphasized that equal status, common goals, cooperation, and supportive norms can strengthen these effects.

But unstructured exposure can also reproduce hierarchy, humiliation, competition, or selective hostility.
Two groups placed in the same room are not necessarily building a relationship.

Constructive contact is more likely when people have:

  • a task they cannot complete as effectively alone;
  • roles that preserve dignity;
  • enough time for individuals to become more than category representatives;
  • protection against domination or harassment;
  • permission to acknowledge real disagreement;
  • and a structure for reflecting on what happened.

The aim is not to manufacture affection.
It is to replace imagined total categories with more accurate human knowledge and some experience of workable interdependence.

Members do not need to become culturally identical or politically close.
They need evidence that the relationship can contain difference without immediately becoming a struggle for survival.


10. Fair Procedures Tell People Whether They Belong

People assess belonging not only by whether they receive the outcome they wanted.
They also assess how decisions are made.

Research on procedural justice finds that people are more willing to accept decisions when they believe they had a meaningful voice, authorities acted neutrally, motives were trustworthy, and participants were treated with dignity and respect. Tom Tyler’s review of outcome and procedure describes these recurring criteria.

This matters deeply in plural societies because no group can win every decision.
If losing always means humiliation, invisibility, or permanent exclusion, each political contest becomes existential.

Fair procedures communicate a different message:
You remain a member of the shared system even when this decision goes against you.

Procedural fairness does not make every outcome just. A formally respectful process can still preserve unequal power or produce serious harm.
But material reform without fair participation can also fail to restore trust. People may experience a technically effective decision as another change imposed upon them.

The OECD’s 2024 survey on drivers of trust in public institutions similarly emphasizes reliability, responsiveness, openness, fairness, and integrity. Its analysis found that responsiveness to evidence, attention to present and future interests, and meaningful political voice were strongly associated with trust in national government.

Institutions maintain belonging when they combine competence with relationship.
People need both functioning systems and evidence that they count within them.


11. Planning Stability Before Pressure Becomes Crisis

Enemy stories grow easily where institutions repeatedly appear surprised by foreseeable change:
A school receives many new pupils but no additional language support.
A region loses major employment without a credible transition plan.
Housing demand rises while construction and local services remain static.
A political institution invites participation only after decisions have effectively been made.
A community experiences rapid demographic change without spaces in which expectations, responsibilities, and fears can be discussed honestly.

In each case, the absence of planning can be interpreted as evidence that someone does not care, that someone else is receiving unfair priority, or that the system has lost control.

Planning for stability means asking before strain becomes severe:

  • What changes are reasonably foreseeable?
  • Which communities will bear the earliest costs?
  • What capacity must grow with the responsibility?
  • Who needs to participate in the design?
  • Which conflicts are likely to emerge?
  • What evidence will show whether the arrangement is working?
  • How can policies be revised without presenting revision as failure?

Planning does not eliminate uncertainty.
It makes uncertainty less available for capture by total threat narratives.


12. Maintenance Is a Form of Recognition

Groups often celebrate founding moments and visible reforms.
They pay less attention to maintenance.

But belonging is frequently decided through ordinary reliability:
Does the office answer?
Does the meeting continue after public attention moves elsewhere?
Is the rule applied consistently?
Does the building remain accessible?
Are new members taught how to participate?
Are complaints examined before they become scandals?
Does someone notice when a policy that once worked is creating new harm?

Maintenance communicates:
Our shared purpose matters enough to be cared for repeatedly.

It also prevents opponents from becoming the group’s main source of energy.

When constructive institutions are poorly maintained, crisis restores attention. Members may learn that only outrage produces action.

Adaptive shared stability therefore requires unglamorous capacities: staffing, listening, repair, institutional memory, succession, evaluation, conflict procedures, and the willingness to update routines.

Maintenance is not the opposite of change.
It is what allows change to become dependable.


13. Belonging Must Be Able to Survive Success

A movement begins because rents are rising rapidly.
It organizes tenants, changes local policy, and helps expand affordable housing.

A party begins because a region has little political representation.
It develops leaders, wins influence, and changes institutional appointments.

A civil-rights organization begins because a population is excluded.
It secures legal protection and greater public recognition.

What happens next?

A healthy group can acknowledge that the original problem has changed. It may protect the gains, address remaining inequalities, transfer its capacity to new needs, or even accept that part of its founding task is complete.

An enemy-dependent group experiences success as a threat to identity.
If the injury diminishes, urgency diminishes.
If the opponent changes, moral clarity weakens.
If cooperation becomes possible, members may fear betrayal…
The movement may then enlarge the danger, reject partial progress, or find a replacement enemy.

Belonging survives success when members are attached not only to the grievance but to capacities developed while addressing it:

  • the ability to organize;
  • the practice of mutual care;
  • knowledge of institutions;
  • democratic participation;
  • shared memory;
  • and confidence that people can respond to new challenges together.

The group’s story becomes:

We came together because something was wrong. We remain connected because we learned how to take responsibility together.


14. Political Parties Need More Than an Oppositional Identity

The two party cases in this series illustrate different forms of political belonging.

Die Linke can build solidarity by connecting experiences of economic insecurity, inequality, and inadequate recognition. Its belonging becomes more constructive when opposition to concentrated power develops into credible institutions, public provision, democratic participation, and forms of solidarity capable of surviving partial improvement.

The AfD can recognize experiences of lost control, institutional distance, and cultural uncertainty. Its belonging becomes less enemy-dependent only if protection is separated from collective suspicion—if boundaries, migration governance, public capacity, and democratic agency can be pursued without requiring minorities or political opponents to symbolize national decline.

These are not equivalent rebalancing tasks.

One cannot infer equal harm, equal exclusion, or equal responsibility simply because both parties organize grievance.

But both cases reveal a question that applies to every oppositional movement:

Can the party describe the society it is capable of building and maintaining, not only the forces it promises to defeat?

Government makes this test unavoidable.

A party in opposition can preserve unity by naming what is wrong.
A party with responsibility must allocate resources, accept evidence, make trade-offs, maintain services, explain limits, correct mistakes, and preserve the membership of citizens who voted against it.

The movement must become capable of more than mobilization.
Its purpose must grow into a profession.


15. Shared Belonging Does Not Require Artificial Symmetry

Calls for unity can become harmful when they erase asymmetry.

If one group is targeted by discrimination, asking both sides simply to reduce hostility can transfer responsibility away from the source of harm.
If one party spreads a false claim and another corrects it, the existence of conflict does not make both statements equally inaccurate.
If an institution protects equal rights against a discriminatory proposal, its boundary is not equivalent to the proposed exclusion.

Belonging without an enemy therefore requires evidence-based asymmetry.

Each action should be assessed according to:

  • what actually occurred;
  • who possessed power;
  • whose rights or safety were affected;
  • whether the response was necessary and proportionate;
  • whether responsibility was assigned precisely;
  • and whether a path toward changed conduct remains possible.

This protects the project from two opposite errors:
The first is moral totalization: one side is imagined as the cause of everything.
The second is false equivalence: all sides are treated as equally responsible because they participate in the same relationship.

Relational understanding asks how actions influence what happens next.
Moral and political judgment asks whether those actions were justified.

We need both.


16. Rebalancing Is a Spiral, Not a Final Settlement

No institution, party, or society reaches a permanent state of balance.

Conditions change.
New members arrive.
Old injuries are remembered differently.
Successful policies create new expectations.
Protective measures produce unintended effects.
The capacities built for one problem may become inadequate for the next…

Rebalancing is therefore not a return to an earlier equilibrium. The earlier arrangement may have been unjust, exclusionary, or incapable of meeting present needs.
Nor is rebalancing a loop that returns the group to the same point.

It is better understood as a spiral:

  1. Recognize what people are experiencing.
  2. Specify the problem, evidence, power, and responsibility.
  3. Protect people and principles through proportionate boundaries.
  4. Build practical capacity and positive shared purpose.
  5. Participate through fair procedures and meaningful roles.
  6. Maintain what has been created before neglect produces another crisis.
  7. Learn from effects, including unintended ones.
  8. Rebalance under changed conditions.

The group revisits familiar questions, but with new knowledge and different capacities.
Adaptive shared stability is not stillness.
It is the ability to change without requiring each change to become a battle for collective survival.


17. A Practical Test for Groups and Institutions

A party, movement, institution, or community can ask:

About purpose

  • What are we trying to make possible?
  • Would that purpose remain meaningful if our main opponent disappeared?
  • Can members describe what we build as clearly as what we resist?

About injury

  • Have we recognized the harm without making grievance permanent?
  • Are responsibility and evidence specific?
  • Do we allow improvement to count as improvement?

About boundaries

  • Are boundaries attached to conduct, or to an allegedly dangerous kind of person?
  • Are they proportionate and reviewable?
  • Is there a dignified path back when changed conduct makes one possible?

About participation

  • Can members influence decisions before a crisis?
  • Are dissent and uncertainty treated as part of belonging rather than immediate disloyalty?
  • Do people retain membership when they lose a legitimate political disagreement?

About capacity

  • Are plans connected to staffing, resources, skills, and maintenance?
  • Do members experience successful cooperation?
  • Can the group adapt without interpreting revision as betrayal?

About the wider relationship

  • Does our internal solidarity make the shared society more capable or less?
  • Are we correcting an actual danger or preserving an emotionally useful enemy?
  • Can we protect people without teaching the next generation whom to hate?

No group will answer every question perfectly.
The purpose of the test is not moral purity.
It is to notice when a necessary conflict has begun to replace the purpose it was meant to serve.


The Belonging Question

The series began with a puzzle:

Why do people so often gather around enemies when they are seeking recognition, protection, agency, and connection?

The answer is not simply that people are irrational or cruel.

An enemy can organize belonging efficiently. It can name pain, simplify uncertainty, clarify boundaries, synchronize emotion, and make collective action feel possible.

But it asks for a dangerous form of dependence:
The group needs the threat to remain believable.
The institution needs the crisis to remain central.
The movement needs every improvement to appear insufficient.
The shared world becomes less secure so that one part of it can feel more coherent.

Belonging without needing an enemy must perform the same human work differently:
It must recognize injury without making grievance permanent.
It must maintain boundaries without turning people into permanent threats.
It must create solidarity through shared practice, not only shared rejection.
It must give people real agency through collective efficacy and meaningful participation.
It must plan for foreseeable pressure, build sufficient capacity, and maintain what has been created.
It must protect difference within a larger “we.”
It must remain morally precise without collapsing comparison into equivalence.
And it must be able to survive success.

The deepest alternative to enemy-dependent belonging is not harmony.
It is a form of connection strong enough to contain conflict without needing conflict to remain its foundation.

The final question is therefore not whether a society can eliminate every enemy.
It is:

Can we build forms of belonging in which people know who they are because of what they are capable of creating, protecting, and maintaining together—not because another group must remain dangerous?

Leave a Reply